World War I as a Revolutionary Moment beyond Europe

AHA Session 129
Saturday, January 4, 2025: 1:30 PM-3:00 PM
Rendezvous Trianon (New York Hilton, Third Floor)
Chair:
Leonard V. Smith, Oberlin College
Papers:
The Ottoman First World War as Revolution
Mustafa Aksakal, Georgetown University
World War I as a Revolutionary Moment in Algeria and Senegal
Elizabeth F. Thompson, American University
Comment:
Leonard V. Smith, Oberlin College

Session Abstract

The study of revolution in the era of World War I has long focused on movements in Europe: communists in Russia, Germany, and Hungary and fascists in Italy. Our session engages with the new global perspective on World War I that has emerged to coincide with its centennial. Historians have only begun to understand the profound impact of the war in Asia and Africa, where some of the war’s worst conflicts were fought and where four million soldiers of color were recruited to support the Allied armies. We present original research using sources in non-European languages on revolutionary movements in South and Southeast Asia, the Ottoman Empire, and French North and West Africa. While each movement was distinct, these cases also suggest ways in which World War I, rather than World War II, might be considered the crucible of global anti-colonialism. In various ways, our papers challenge enduring European narratives rooted in colonial perspectives of a century ago. Revolutionary leaders were not narrow or naïve nationalists; nor did they lead merely spontaneous uprisings. We offer evidence of that they built collective movements around shared goals to disrupt-- or transform-- an unjust world order.

The first paper uses memoirs, court records, and oral history interviews. This paper examines how the 1915 rebellion in Singapore expressed growing anti-colonial sentiment among Indian soldiers and tentative inter-ethnic anticolonial alliances. This perspective contrasts with British reports that dismissed the rebellion as a mere mutiny staged by foreign infiltrators of Muslim fanatics. The second paper challenges prevailing views of the Ottoman entry into World War I as an anti-revolutionary adventure by the military dictatorship of the Young Turks. Ottoman wartime policy is better explained as a continuation of revolutionary agendas that had inspired the 1908 constitutional revolution—not as a break with it. The 1908 goals of government centralization and silencing of opposition persisted through the war and shaped the 1923 establishment of the Turkish republic. By drawing together the usually distinct historiography of Senegal and Algeria, the third paper argues that a revolutionary moment emerged in the French empire in 1918-1919 under the leadership of longtime anti-colonialist Georges Clemenceau. Local politicians tapped the discontent and expectations of war veterans to mount movements to claim the rights of citizenship and representation within the French Empire. The paper challenges a historiography that has dismissed the reforms enacted as unimportant because they did not endure: as historians have long viewed World War I in Europe as a dynamic of revolution and counterrevolution, so too might we understand a similar dynamic in North and West Africa.

See more of: AHA Sessions