Migration, Surveillance, and Sending States: The Case for Transnational Perspectives

AHA Session 59
Immigration and Ethnic History Society 1
Saturday, January 4, 2025: 8:30 AM-10:00 AM
Madison Square (Sheraton New York, Lower Level)
Chair:
Maddalena Marinari, Gustavus Adolphus College
Panel:
Lauren Braun-Strumfels, Cedar Crest College
Mark Choate, Brigham Young University
Matthew Guariglia, Emory University
Linda Reeder, University of Missouri

Session Abstract

How Italy and the United States cooperated to manage mass migration beginning in the late nineteenth century presents a compelling case for the necessity of understanding the evolution of migration policy in a transnational frame. While much recent scholarship has exposed how efforts to manage migration in receiving countries shaped ideas about race, gender, ethnicity, national-belonging, and transnational lives, there has been less research on the role sending countries played in defining the contours and implementation of immigration legislation, or how these laws passed abroad informed understandings of mobility and social hierarchies at home. Through a focus on the history of migration between Italy and the United States, this roundtable highlights the links between xenophobia, immigration restrictions, and the inclusion of state and non-state actors in regulatory processes to show how immigration laws are not made solely in one country, but emerge out of transnational concerns about mobility, the health and security of the nation, and geopolitical ambitions.


Audience members interested in migration, borderlands, and the state will engage with panelists who are experts in policy and political history and who examine migration through the lenses of gender, policing, and surveillance studies. The regulatory history of Italy and the United States offers new ways of thinking about the gendered and racial dimensions of migration, and the role legal migration restrictions played in the expansion of transnational surveillance technologies. The panelists on this roundtable, who are chapter contributors and editors of the new anthology Managing Migration in Italy and the United States (DeGruyter, 2024), will explore the understudied links between the history of immigration regulation and state surveillance. They will ask the audience to think hard about the ways in which the history of migration regulations in the United States and Italy is inextricably linked to the expansion of surveillance systems as laws requiring visas, passports, medical checkpoints, medical inspections, and quarantines all transformed migration into a critical site of surveillance. Requirements for new kinds of documentation generated a transnational legion of medical experts, steamship captains, immigration officials, diplomats, police, and neighbors enlisted in attesting to who had the right to travel while the widening of state surveillance mechanisms reified gender and racial norms. Given the ways in which surveillance is inextricably linked to the disciplining of the social body and the construction of social hierarchies, the panelists on this roundtable seek to open new ways of thinking about how restrictive legislation transformed mobile bodies into social threats, requiring ever more comprehensive systems of surveillance that mark law-abiding bodies from the transgressive ones.

See more of: AHA Sessions