Beyond the Essay: Creative Assignments for Active Learning in High School and College History Classes

AHA Session 269
Sunday, January 10, 2027: 9:00 AM-10:30 AM
Grand Ballroom A (Sheraton New Orleans, 5th Floor)
Chair:
Anna Bennett, Hollins University
Discussion:
Gabriela Faundez Mullins, St. Catherine's School
Participant:
Nelson Marques, Doral Academy Preparatory School
Papers:
The Sum of All Parts: Student Portfolios as Unit Assessments
Nelson Marques, Doral Academy Preparatory School
Into the Trenches: Using Virtual Reality to Teach World War I
Gabriela Faundez Mullins, St. Catherine's School

Session Abstract

This lightning-round panel will bring together history educators from high schools and colleges to showcase substantive, nontraditional assignments that replace or significantly reframe the traditional exam or research essay. Each presenter will offer a five-minute overview of a major course project including a podcast, an immersive virtual reality learning experience, and digital writing portfolios, multimodal assignments that serves as a central assessment in their curriculum.

Collectively, these assignments demonstrate how creative formats can clarify student learning goals and make disciplinary skills more visible. Rather than treating alternative projects as enrichment activities, panelists position them as fresh strategies for teaching core historical skills like primary source analysis, historiographical engagement, argumentative writing, revision, and audience awareness. By asking students to communicate history in new forms, these assignments foreground research, analytical writing, and evidence-based storytelling while helping students see history as an active and constantly evolving practice rather than a static body of knowledge.

These assignments treat educators as active participants in the learning process by making student gaps more intelligible and opening new avenues towards differentiated learning. In lieu of the often-strict binary of standardized test and final essays, these assignments serve as nexus for new modalities in assessing student shortcomings with high level and skill specific examples. For educators these alternative assessments offer a potentially comprehensive means to more effectively differentiate instruction based on student needs and classroom goals.

We aim to structure this lightning-round session around shared guiding questions, such as: What learning problem prompted this assignment? How does it scaffold research, writing, and/or digital literacies? How is it assessed? By foregrounding multiple assignment examples, our panel will model intentional course design across diverse institutional contexts. The session will then turn to a facilitated discussion inviting attendees to reflect on a range of creative assessment strategies in their own classrooms. By examining alternatives to the exam or essay, this panel seeks to spark conversation among history educators from a diverse range of institutions about how creative assignments can sharpen pedagogical purpose while sustaining disciplinary rigor in the history classroom.

See more of: AHA Sessions