Nature in an Unnatural Environment: Agriculture As "God’s Gift" in Imperial Germany

Saturday, January 5, 2013: 2:50 PM
Oakley Room (Sheraton New Orleans)
Kevin D. Goldberg, Brown University
“Nature in an Unnatural Environment: Agriculture as ‘God’s Gift’ in Imperial Germany”

 The historical discipline’s continued preference for defining “nature” within the context of the environment has proven too narrow, and as a consequence has led historians too far astray in their search for nature’s broader meaning. In the realm of Imperial German agriculture, nature came increasingly to be defined as a set of practices, often stressing traditional processes and resistances to industrialization, rather than a specific environmental or geographic place. Artisanal German vintners were the first in Europe to define their wines as natural, buffering themselves from the socially disruptive technological advances of nineteenth-century winemaking. In doing so, “nature” was appropriated as a defensive tool to ward off the democratizing effects of rational enology. Subsequently, the land—in the form of the vineyard—was made to appear to have unique, God-given characteristics, a forerunner to today’s notion of terroir. This talk will critique nature within “unnatural environments” by addressing its rootedness in agricultural practices and social dislocations.